Skip to content
  • Finnish Government
    • Prime Minister's Office
    • Ministry of Defence
    • Ministry of Transport and Communications
    • Ministry for Foreign Affairs
    • Ministry of Finance
    • Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment
    • Ministry of Justice
    • Ministry of Education and Culture
    • Ministry of Social Affairs and Health
    • Ministry of the Interior
    • Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry
    • Ministry of the Environment

Valitse kieli:

This page is in Finnish. Go to the English site »

Or choose language:

Den här sidan är på finska. Gå till den svenska versionen av sidan »

Eller välj språk:

Dát siidu lea suomagillii. Sirdás davvisámegielat siidduide »

Dahje vállje giela:

Язык этого сайта финский. Перейти на русскоязычный сайт »

Или выберите язык:

Cette page est en finnois. Aller sur le site en français »

Ou choisir la langue:

Diese Seite ist auf Finnisch. Wechseln Sie zur deutschen Version »

Oder wählen Sie Ihre Sprache:

Tämä sivu on englanniksi. Siirry suomenkieliseen sivustoon »

Tai valitse kieli:

Choose language:

Den här sidan är på engelska. Gå till den svenska versionen av sidan »

Eller välj språk:

Язык этого сайта английский. Перейти на русскоязычный сайт »

Или выберите язык:

Dát siidu lea eŋgelasgillii. Sirdás davvisámegielat siidduide »

Dahje vállje giela:

Cette page est en anglais. Aller sur le site en français »

Ou choisir la langue:

Diese Seite ist auf Englisch. Wechseln Sie zur deutschen Version »

Oder wählen Sie Ihre Sprache:

Tämä sivu on ruotsiksi. Siirry suomenkieliseen sivustoon »

Tai valitse kieli:

This page is in Swedish. Go to the English site »

Or choose language:

Välj språk:

Язык этого сайта шведский. Перейти на русскоязычный сайт »

Или выберите язык:

Dát siidu lea eŋgelasgillii. Sirdás davvisámegielat siidduide »

Dahje vállje giela:

Cette page est en suédois. Aller sur le site en français »

Ou choisir la langue:

Diese Seite ist auf Schwedisch. Wechseln Sie zur deutschen Version »

Oder wählen Sie Ihre Sprache:

Tämä sivu on pohjois-saameksi. Siirry suomenkieliseen sivustoon »

Tai valitse kieli:

This page is in North Saami. Go to the English site »

Or choose language:

Den här sidan är på nordsamiska. Gå till den svenska versionen av sidan »

Eller välj språk:

Язык этого сайта северосаамский. Перейти на русскоязычный сайт »

Или выберите язык:

Vállje giela:

Cette page est en same du Nord. Aller sur le site en français »

Ou choisir la langue:

Diese Seite ist auf Nordsamisch. Wechseln Sie zur deutschen Version »

Oder wählen Sie Ihre Sprache:

Tämä sivu on venäjäksi. Siirry suomenkieliseen sivustoon »

Tai valitse kieli:

This page is in Russian. Go to the English site »

Or choose language:

Den här sidan är på ryska. Gå till den svenska versionen av sidan »

Eller välj språk:

Dát siidu lea ruoššagillii. Sirdás davvisámegielat siidduide »

Dahje vállje giela:

выберите язык:

Cette page est en russe. Aller sur le site en français »

Ou choisir la langue:

Diese Seite ist auf Russisch. Wechseln Sie zur deutschen Version »

Oder wählen Sie Ihre Sprache:

Tämä sivu on ranskaksi. Siirry suomenkieliseen sivustoon »

Tai valitse kieli:

This page is in French. Go to the English site »

Or choose language:

Den här sidan är på franska. Gå till den svenska versionen av sidan »

Eller välj språk:

Dát siidu lea fránskkagillii. Sirdás davvisámegielat siidduide »

Dahje vállje giela:

Язык этого сайта французский. Перейти на русскоязычный сайт »

Или выберите язык:

Choisir la langue:

Diese Seite ist auf Französisch. Wechseln Sie zur deutschen Version »

Oder wählen Sie Ihre Sprache:

Tämä sivu on saksaksi. Siirry suomenkieliseen sivustoon »

Tai valitse kieli:

This page is in German. Go to the English site »

Or choose language:

Den här sidan är på tyska. Gå till den svenska versionen av sidan »

Eller välj språk:

Язык этого сайта немецкий. Перейти на русскоязычный сайт »

Или выберите язык:

Cette page est en allemand. Aller sur le site en français »

Ou choisir la langue:

Wählen Sie Ihre Sprache:

  • Valitse kieli Suomi
  • Välj språket Svenska
  • Select language English
  • Vállje giela Davvisámegiella
Media
Ministry of Social Affairs and Health
Navigation
  • Frontpage Frontpage
  • Areas of expertise
    • Promotion of welfare Health promotion, harm and crime prevention, environmentional health, inclusion
    • Social and health services Services, healthcare and social welfare system, wellbeing services counties, status of clients, personnel, pharmacotherapy
    • Income security Allowances and benefits, pensions
    • Insurance Insurance institutions, statutory insurance
    • Working life Occupational safety and health, wellbeing at work
    • Gender equality Gender equality policy, equal pay
    • EU and international cooperation EU, Nordic cooperation, WHO, UN, ILO
    • Preparedness Preparedness planning, Medical Helpline 116 117
  • Current issues
  • Columns
  • Projects and legislation
  • Publications
  • Ministry
  • Contact
  • Press releases
  • News
  • MSAH on social media
  • Statistics
  • Sign up for news
  • Service by publication
suomiLue artikkeli suomeksi svenskaLäs artikeln på svenska English

Report on alternative ways of organising social security published

Ministry of Social Affairs and Health
Publication date 10.1.2023 9.01
Type:Press release
Kuvituskuva

Different ways of organising social security have been examined as part of the preparation of the social security reform. The report on alternative ways of organising social security, which was made by a working group consisting of researchers and experts, was published on Tuesday 10 January 2023.

The report assesses whether alternative ways of organising social security — primarily basic income, a social account and one basic security benefit together with a participation supplement — are suitable for the Finnish social security system. The report also provides an overview of the discussion on ways to organise social security and of the previous experiments and impact assessments and then compares the basic principles for different ways of organising social security with those of the current system.

“The report combines in an interesting way the theory and practice of social security, i.e. the choices of principle and the impacts that these choices would have. Both of these aspects should be taken into account during discussions,” says Research Manager Jussi Tervola of the Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, who is also the chair of the working group.

Assessment focused on basic income, social account, and one basic security benefit and participation supplement

Ways of organising social security could be implemented using a number of different methods, and their impact would vary depending on how they are implemented. Because of this, the working group created example models for organising social security, and the report assesses the impacts of these models. In its impact assessment, the working group decided to focus on the following three models that are assessed in light of the current system:

  • basic income  
  • social account  
  • one basic security benefit and participation supplement.

According to the basic income model, a basic income equal to the amount of current basic security would be paid to all people aged 18–64 who are not on pension (EUR 742 per month). The basic income would replace the basic security benefits, the basic amount of the earnings-related benefits, the study grant for those aged 18 or over, and the child home care allowance. The report also assesses a lower-level basic income (EUR 256 per month).
  
Under the social account model, payments made to fund benefits would be directed to a personal account. The model examined by the working group would cover unemployment security and financial aid for students, but in other respects, the current system would remain unchanged. Unemployment benefits and student financial aid would reduce the account balance. The account surplus would be available for personal use when the account holder retires, for example. In the social account model, the levels of benefits and the conditions for receiving benefits would remain unchanged.
  
The working group has also examined the model for one basic security benefit and participation supplement. In this model outlined by the working group, the basic component of one basic security benefit would combine the basic security benefits for working-age people and the study grant. The child home care allowance and the informal care support would form the care component. People would receive a participation supplement on top of the basic component when they meet the participation criterion.

The report also assesses the impact on different groups of beneficiaries and other groups of people as well as on costs and the funding structure. The impacts of different ways of organising social security are also assessed in light of the key problems highlighted by the social security reform. These problems include the complexity of social security, the reconciliation of benefits and gainful employment, the role of last-resort financial assistance and the link to services.

All models provide solutions to some of these problems, but at the same time they may also exacerbate other problems. In addition, there is considerable uncertainty involved in anticipating the impact of major changes, and research data on behavioural impacts in particular is scarce. 

“Major changes in social security may affect people’s behaviour in a way that is difficult to predict. Experiments provide solutions to these only to a very limited extent,” says Tervola.

When it comes to the example models, a number of choices were made that would, in reality, require political discussion. The models are rough outlines, and they cannot be adopted as such.

Results to be used in the work of the Social Security Committee

The Social Security Committee is preparing an interim report, which will be published in March 2023. The interim report will set the guidelines for reforming social security and make proposals for reforms concerning the current system that the next Government can include in its programme. Examining alternative ways to organise social security is part of the Committee’s work during its first term. Over the course of last autumn, the Committee discussed the alternative of harmonising basic security benefits in particular.
 
“The study conducted by the working group provides a solid basis for a further study on harmonising and combining basic security benefits, although this would entail a more advanced model than what the Committee is proposing,” says Pasi Moisio, Chair of the Social Security Committee.

  • Report: Study on alternative ways of organising social securityLink to an external website

Inquiries

Jussi Tervola, Research Manager, chair of the working group, tel. +358 29 524 6134 firstname.lastname@thl.fi
Pasi Moisio, Research Professor, Chair of the Social Security Committee, tel. +358 29 524 7228, firstname.lastname@thl.fi
 

Sosiaaliturvauudistus
basic income guarantee basic security benefits reforms social insurance social security
Back to top
Ministry of Social Affairs and health
Sosiaali- ja terveysministeriö
Social- och hälsovårdsministeriet

Meritullinkatu 8, 00170 Helsinki

PL 33, 00023 Government, Finland

Switchboard +358 295 16001

registry.stm(at)gov.fi 

About the site

Data Protection

Sitemap

Accessibility statement for the stm.fi website

Feedback

Search page
  • Frontpage
  • Areas of expertise
    • Promotion of welfare
      • Legislation
      • Health promotion
        • Fighting infectious disease
          • Fighting infectious disease: Responsibilities of the authorities
          • COVID-19 disease in Finland
            • Press releases about Coronavirus
          • Avian influenza
      • Promoting participation
        • Key areas of participation and inclusion
        • Roma policy
        • Immigrants' social security, welfare and health
      • Substance harm prevention
        • Alcohol policy
          • Alcohol Act
        • Drug policy
          • Narcotics control
        • Tobacco and nicotine policy
          • EU regulation and cooperation
          • Other authorities’ responsibilities
          • Actions to reduce the use
          • Interaction with the tobacco industry
        • Harm caused by gambling
          • Gambling Policy Programme
          • Assessment of risks associated with gambling
          • Parties responsible for gambling policy
          • Gambling system
      • Preventing violence and crime
        • Combating domestic and intimate partner violence
          • NAPE – Committee for Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence
        • Combating trafficking in human beings
        • Mediation in criminal and civil cases
        • Violence against children and its prevention
        • Responsibilities in preventing domestic and family violence
      • Environmental health
        • Radiation protection
        • Chemical oversight
          • Cosmetic products
          • Tattoos
      • Advisory Board for Public Health
    • Social and health services
      • Legislation
        • Children, young people and families
        • Old people
        • Secondary use of health and social data
          • Frequently asked questions about the Act on Secondary Use of Health and Social Data
          • Amending the Act on the Secondary Use of Health and Social Data
      • Responsible agencies
        • Wellbeing services counties
          • Wellbeing services counties on the map
          • Guidance of the wellbeing services counties
          • Collaborative areas
        • Municipalities
        • Supervisory authorities
        • Private providers of health and social services
        • Centres of excellence on social welfare
        • Organisations and associations
      • Social services
        • Disability services
        • Child welfare
          • Frequently asked questions concerning child welfare in Finland
      • Health services
        • Primary health care
          • Screening
            • Prenatal screening
          • Vaccinations
            • HPV vaccinations
          • Maternity and child health clinics
          • School health care
          • Student health care
        • Occupational health care
        • Private health care
        • Mental health services
        • Services for substance abusers
        • Hospitals and specialised medical care
        • Urgent and emergency health services
        • Client and patient safety
        • Healthcare and social welfare for undocumented persons
        • Termination of pregnancy
      • Rehabilitation
      • Pharmacotherapy
        • Value chain for pharmacotherapy
        • Legislation, steering and supervision, cooperation
        • Safety of pharmacotherapy
        • Rational pharmacotherapy
          • Implementation of sensible pharmacotherapy
          • Information management
            • Digital services
      • Client and patient rights
      • Client fees
      • Social and health care personnel
      • Children, youth and families
        • Services to families
      • Older people services
        • Services and benefits
      • Social security and services of asylum seekers in Finland
        • Healthcare and social welfare for illegal residents
        • Health and social services for people arriving from Ukraine
      • Information management
    • Income security
      • Legislation
      • Financial assistance for families with children
      • Conscripts allowance
      • Housing allowance
      • Unemployment
      • Sickness and rehabilitation
      • Pensions
        • Earnings-related pension
        • National pension
        • Guarantee pension
        • Disability pension
        • Survivors’ pension
      • Front veterans
      • Social security for athletes, grant recipients and students
      • Social assistance
      • Social lending
      • Support and benefits
      • International social security
      • Appealing income security decisions
      • Occupational accidents and illnesses
    • Insurance
      • Legislation and oversight
      • Insurance institutions
      • Supervision of the insurance sector
      • Investing insurance contributions
      • Statutory insurance
      • Social insurance contribution
      • Insurance related appeals
    • Working life
      • Legislation
      • Posted workers
      • Generally applicable collective agreements
      • Occupational safety and health
      • Supervising OSH
        • European cooperation on market surveillance
        • Workplace harassment
        • Vera ICT System
      • Occupational health care and maintaining work ability
        • Value of lost labour input in Finland
      • Wellbeing at work
      • Equality in working life
      • Young people and work
      • Family life and work
      • Older workers
    • Gender equality
      • Legislation
      • Mainstreaming
      • Gender equality in working life
      • Equal pay
      • International cooperation
      • Responsible agencies
      • Projects on gender equality
    • EU and international cooperation
    • Preparedness
  • Current issues
    • Press releases
    • News
    • MSAH on social media
    • Statistics
      • Statistics on the promotion of welfare and health
      • Statistics on social welfare and health care services
      • Statistics on income
      • Statistics on insurance
      • Statistics on employment
      • Statistics on equality
      • International statistics
    • Sign up for news
    • Service by publication
  • Columns
  • Projects and legislation
    • National service reform
    • Defining the principles for service choices in healthcare and social welfare
    • Social security reform
      • General social security benefit
    • Mental health policy strategy
    • Child Strategy
      • Preparations for a National Child Strategy in 2018-2019
    • RDI Growth Programme for Health and Wellbeing
    • Reducing homelessness with better-targeted health and social services
    • Sustainable Growth Programme for Finland
    • The European Accessibility Act
    • Personalized medicine
      • Improving health through the use of genomic data
      • Overall project description
      • Genome Center
      • National Cancer Center
      • Biobank Operations
      • National neurocenter
      • Drug Development Centre
      • People and contact details
      • European ‘1+ Million Genomes’ Initiative
    • Sufficiency and availability of healthcare and social welfare personnel
    • National health and wellbeing programme Terveydeksi
    • Completed projects
  • Publications
  • Ministry
    • Task and objectives
    • Management and organisation
      • Minister of Social Affairs and Health
      • Minister of Social Security
      • Senior Civil Servants
      • Department for Steering of Healthcare and Social Welfare (OHO)
      • Department for Insurance and Social Security (SVO)
      • Department for Safety, Security and Health (TUTO)
      • Department for Communities and Functional Capacity (YTO)
        • YPA - personnel
      • Department for Clients and Services in Healthcare and Social Welfare (APO)
      • Department for Work and Gender Equality (TTO)
      • Strategic and Financial Management Unit (STAR)
      • Human Resources and Administration Unit (HEHA)
      • International Affairs Unit (KVY)
      • Communications Unit (VIE)
      • Responsibilities of ministers in the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health
    • Strategy
      • Economy of wellbeing
    • Administrative branch
    • Preparedness
      • Preparedness centres
      • Preparedness in the EU
      • Radiation accidents
      • Preparedness in Wellbeing Services Counties
      • Preparedness in wellbeing services counties
    • International cooperation
      • European Union
        • Preparation of EU affairs
      • Council of Europe
        • European Committee of Social Rights
      • United Nations
      • World Health Organization
        • WHO pandemic treaty
      • Global health security
      • Nordic cooperation
        • Finland's Presidency of the Nordic Council of Ministers in 2021
      • Northern Dimension
      • Barents cooperation
      • Arctic cooperation
      • International Labour Organization
      • OECD
    • Economy and activities
    • Forms
    • STEA grants
    • Expenditure
    • Advisory boards and commitees
    • The Ministry as a workplace
      • Working for the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health
      • Ministry personnel statistics
      • Principles of a safer space
      • Read more about jobs
    • Services
    • History
    • Whistleblower protection
  • Contact
    • Personnel search
    • E-invoice address
    • For media
    • Feedback
    • Data Protection
      • User's rights and requests for personal data
      • Information system descriptions
      • Publicity of documents and requests for information
      • Information on cookies on the website
    • Accessibility statement for the stm.fi website